I call it: "F the system". As in:
"F the system man. I ain't in this to make money, I'm in this to make art!"
Or:
"I'm trying to write the next “Rashomon” not the next “Paul Blart”! F the system!"
I understand this phase. I went through this phase myself. I think everyone has to. But it has to be a phase, not a mantra.
There comes a time in every writers life where you have to give up the idea that you’re going to write Godfather 4. You can’t do that right from the start. You have to work your way up. You might have to settle for Paul Blart 2. So why fight the system now?
You know who I blame for this phase? Independent directors. When it comes to filmmaking, independent directors have it the easiest. They don't have as many people looking over their shoulders. They have the freedom to create whatever idea pops in their heads. And an entire independent movement to support their every whim. They have one undeniable factor that allows them to "F the system".
They're not spec writers.
If you're a spec writer, you have rules to follow. Hollywood doesn't give a crap about you "not wanting to write sympathetic characters" or you wanting to write an ending where "everyone dies and no one is happy". Hollywood doesn't like those things. And you shouldn't either. Because if you don't play by the rules, then you don't get to play.
And if you are one of those Hollywood Haters reading this right now, I know exactly what you're thinking: "F this sellout. Why doesn't he shut up and go watch Twilight?"
First of all, “Twilight” sucks.
Second of all, that’s not a bad idea. In my opinion, if you’re a spec writer, you should be REQUIRED to see “Twilight”. And the rest of the sequels. As a spec writer, you NEED to go see the “Twilight’s”, the “Paul Blart’s”, the “Tooth Fairy’s” and everything else that hits a hundred million. Because that’s what’s selling. Do you think I went to see “Transformers 2” for fun?
You need to study not just the good films but the bad ones. For every “Inglorious Bastards” there has to be a “G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra”. If you see “The Hangover”, you have to see “It’s Complicated”. The good with the bad. One for you, one for your craft. Watch these movies. Read the scripts. And figure out how the structure worked.
Uh oh. Did I just say the “S” word?
“Structure?! F’n structure?! This guy wants me to write something formulaic! F this guy, I’m gonna go watch Pulp Fiction for the fifteenth time!”
Look buddy, I hear you. When you’re first starting out, structure is a dirty word. But right now it needs to be your best friend. Better yet, your significant other.
Next time you go to the movies, bring structure along as your date. Hold hands with structure as you talk to each other about where you think act two begins or what you think the inciting incident was. You and structure will have a fantastic evening.
BECAUSE YOU NEED STRUCTURE.
I don’t know how to make that clearer for you Hollywood Haters. You can’t just have people sitting about talking to each other. Yes it does happen in movies. Yes it does happen in great movies. But if you do a little research on those movies, you’ll notice that most of them were made by independent filmmakers.
You’re a spec writer.
So next time you write a script, try to make sure that something happens. If it’s just a bunch of people talking, it’s going to get boring for the reader. Fast.
It's very true that the best movies of all time, barely follow structure. You're not wrong. But every reader in Hollywood is looking for a writer that understands structure. That's the way it is in the system. So to get your foot in the door, you're going to have to learn it. Once you are in, write what ever you want. More power to you. But in the mean time:
Act 1, Act 2a, Act 2b and Act 3. Learn it, live it and stop complaining about it.
Learn the rules of spec writing. Hold on to these rules as if your career depends on it.
Because they do.
Remember:
When you try to F the system, you just F yourself.